With the November 3 midterm elections approaching, Americans are wondering what the results could mean for the economy, stock market, and real estate. Does the economy perform better when the president’s party controls Congress, or when voters hand one or both chambers to the opposition? We examined historical stock market and housing data to identify patterns. The results may surprise you.
Stock Market Historically Performs Well After Midterms
Historically, the stock market has performed well following midterm elections regardless of which party controls Congress. One study found that when the president’s party retained the House and Senate, the S&P 500 averaged an 18% gain over the following 12 months. When the president’s party lost one or both chambers, the average gain was approximately 12%.
Both scenarios produced positive average returns, although retaining control appeared to offer an advantage. Looking at the two years following selected midterms reveals another pattern.
After the 1994 election, when Democrats lost both chambers, stocks gained approximately 69% over the following two calendar years. Following the 2002 election, when Republicans gained full control of Congress, stocks rose approximately 43%. Following the 2018 midterms, when Republicans lost the House, stocks gained nearly 56% over the next two calendar years.
However, following the 2006 election, when Republicans lost both chambers, stocks declined approximately 34% over the next two years as the financial crisis unfolded. The lesson? Election outcomes matter, but economic conditions matter more.
Real Estate Tells a Different Story
National home prices over the two years following midterm elections are far less predictable.Following the 1978 midterms, when Democrats maintained congressional control, national home prices increased approximately 19.5%.After the 1994 election, when Republicans captured both chambers, home prices increased approximately 7.2%.
Following the 2002 election, home prices climbed approximately 18%, while after the 2006 election, they declined approximately 8.2% as the housing crisis intensified. After the 2010 election, national home prices declined approximately 2.8%. Following the 2018 and 2022 elections, prices increased approximately 11.6% and 10.9%, respectively.
Housing appreciation has occurred under both unified and divided government. Declines have occurred as well. There isn’t enough consistent evidence to suggest either congressional outcome produces a stronger housing market.
What About Southwest Florida Real Estate?
We also considered how these patterns might apply to Fort Myers, Cape Coral, and Southwest Florida. Unfortunately, Southwest Florida real estate data is just as inconclusive as national housing data when comparing congressional election outcomes.
Our market has experienced appreciation, corrections, changing inventory, and major shifts in buyer demand under different political configurations. Southwest Florida also responds to influences national statistics don’t fully capture, including migration, hurricanes, insurance costs, new construction, and seasonal demand.
Predicting local home prices simply by knowing which party wins Congress would be a mistake.
What Really Drives Home Prices?
Mortgage rates, employment, affordability, consumer confidence, and housing inventory generally influence real estate more than congressional control. Lower mortgage rates increase buyer purchasing power. Rising inventory gives buyers more negotiating leverage. Higher insurance premiums can make an otherwise affordable home difficult to purchase. These measurable factors affect actual real estate transactions.
Looking Ahead to 2027 and 2028
Whether Republicans retain Congress or Democrats capture one or both chambers, history doesn’t provide a reliable forecast for Southwest Florida home prices. For sellers, pricing correctly and understanding competing inventory remain critical. Buyers should evaluate affordability, available choices, and long-term plans rather than making decisions based on election results.
The bottom line is simple: Elections may influence economic policy, but they don’t determine real estate values.
In Southwest Florida, we’ll continue watching the numbers that actually move the market. When buying or selling real estate, data beats political speculation every time.
Thinking of Selling?
Always call the Ellis Team – KW Florida Living 239-489-4042 or visit www.Topagent.com for the latest market stats and Southwest Florida real estate news.
Southwest Florida Housing Alert Video

Brett Ellis and his mother, Sande Ellis, lead Ellis Team – KW Florida Living in Fort Myers, Florida, with more than 38 years in Southwest Florida real estate. The team has closed more than 6,000 transactions since 1987 and ranked #2 in Fort Myers by transactions in 2025 (RealTrends Verified). Brett writes a weekly real estate column for The News-Press and publishes the team’s Lee County market indices, including the Current Market Index™ and Market Spread Index™. The team is a proud member of SWFL Inc. Learn more at TopAgent.com.