We’ve added the first of many new community pages dedicated to neighborhoods in SW Florida. Reflection Lakes is our first. This page will be updated soon with a new and better look.
SW Florida Building Permits Slowed From Record Levels in 2005. Permit activity in the SW Florida real estate market was off compared to record 2005 levels. Builders are less likely to pull permits for speculation construction with the amount of resale inventory on the market, and investors looking to flip for a quick buck have dried up. That leaves builders with the normal buyer contracts, and even that has slowed from 2005 levels.
In 2005 buyers bought new construction at record levels for a few reasons. First, because there was a severe shortage of homes on the market, and new construction was Plan B and served as backup inventory. Secondly, investors liked buying at pre-construction prices, and the building process gave them time to find a buyer for that home so they could make a nice profit without hopefully ever having to own the home. Investors serve as financiers so to speak and helped speed up supply.
Demand from end users never changed very much. We had artificial demand which the investors created, which made the market appear much better than it really was. While we had artificial demand, we now have Real Supply. When you mix Real supply with Normal demand, you have a Buyers Market.
Buyers are in the driver’s seat, no question. The only question is the speed at which they are driving, and how long it will last. We are starting to see signs of increased buyer activity. This is welcomed news for many. Many buyers were sitting on the sideline waiting for somebody to give the “All Clear, it’s OK to buy now signal.”
Many buyers have heard the signal and are stepping back in. The market may not be All Clear in all segments; however we are seeing very nice activity in certain segments.
Mixed Messages: Many buyers think when they hear the words “Buyer’s Market” that they own the road. Buyers still need to be aware that many properties are pried very well. Those sellers are successful at selling in this market. It’s not like we don’t have any buyers, we certainly do. We have normal buyer activity just like we’ve always had. Because the best properties always sell, buyers are not in competition with the seller for those properties. Buyers are in competition with other buyers who will scoop up the property and steal it from them.
So, if you’re a buyer and see a property you like and is priced well, don’t sit too long. The best values are selling, and you’ll be on your 2nd, 3rd, or 4th choice before you know it. The only good news is that if you can live with your 2nd -4th choice, they are there for you this year. Last year you didn’t have a 4th choice.
Single family home sales in the Fort Myers Cape Coral real estate market dropped 36% from 2005 levels in September, down from 1,075 sales last year to 693 sales this year. SW Florida Real Estate Market Report shows median prices dropped 9% since last year from $288,700 down to $261,400
Sales actually increased since August 2006 from 691 to 693 sales. Prices remained relatively steady since August 2006. September prices came in at $261,400, down from $264,100 in August.
Single family home sales and prices in Lee County seem to have leveled off, and this could be a silver lining. Many national experts predicted sales prices would fall in SW Florida about 18% from it’s all-time high. We’ve already seen a 15-20% price drop, so then end may be near. Inventory is still rising, and pending sales have dropped slightly, not encouraging news.
What is encouraging is the rate of homes coming on the market is dropping, and the decrease in pending activity is dropping as well, signaling a leveling off may occur sometime in the future. Showings have also actually increased, which could lead to an increase in pending sales down the road.
Additionally, pending sales are picking up in other parts of the country, which may affect home buyers looking to purchase here. We still have a lot of inventory, but there are some really great buys out there now awaiting home buyers, and we think now is the time for buyers to pounce. We won’t know exactly when the market has hit bottom and starts to go back up. What we can say is that there are definite signs a leveling off maybe close at hand. Until that leveling off actually occurs and we start eating into existing inventory levels, we can’t officially say we’re at the bottom. Stay tuned.
Condo sales in Lee County were off 52% from 126 sales in September 2005 to 61 in 2006. Sales prices of condos in Lee County were down 3% from $314,800 in September 2005 to $305,600 in 2006
Collier County single family home sales were down 37% from 377 in September 2005 to 236 in September 2006. Sale prices were down 8% from $487,500 last year to $446,900. Naples condo sales were down 62% from 456 condo sales last year to 173 this year. Sale prices were actually up 4% from $365,700 last year to $378,600
We think this is partly the reason sales in Naples are down because sellers haven’t reacted as quickly to changing prices as sellers have in Lee County. We believe sales are much closer to leveling off in Lee County than they are in Collier County because of this fact. Affordability and price are a much larger issue in today’s market. It’s total cost of ownership, not just the price. As homeowners insurance goes up, property taxes goes up, interest rates, gas, etc it eventually weighs down on buyers. There is too much price disparity right now between Naples and Fort Myers. Soon you will see another rush of buyers purchasing in Lee County because Collier County is just so expensive.
Naples is a beautiful place to live, as is Fort Myers, The address won’t matter as much going forward as price will. Collier County is poised to lose buyers to Lee County, just as Lee County will lose some buyers to Charlotte County for the same reasons. Housing affordability.
What comes first, the chicken or the egg? Or is it Residential roof tops Vs. Commercial businesses in downtown Fort Myers real estate?
This is the question. Retailers, bars, and restaurants needs consumers, and consumers want businesses before they decide to live in an area. This scenario has been playing out for the better part of 3 years now. Investors have lined up and purchased units, however downtown needs end users for a vibrant business climate.
This could all be about to change, just not overnight. It’s still a process, and we’re in the middle of it now. Within 5 years we’ll see significant change. The issue is how many are willing to wait, and for how long?
We’ll be sure to keep you posted on downtown Fort Myers development in the future.
Florida Sales Report 2nd Quarter
ORLANDO, Fla., August 15, 2006 — In second quarter 2006, Florida’s housing sector followed the national trend, showing signs of a market adjusting to a better balance between buyers and sellers. Statewide sales of single-family existing homes totaled 53,161 during the three-month period, a decrease of 27 percent compared to 72,870 homes sold during the same time a year ago, according to the Florida Association of Realtors® (FAR).
“Sales of existing single-family homes in Florida behaved like much of the U.S. in the 2006 second quarter, with the declining strength of the domestic economy continuing to act like a stiff wind in the face of the existing real estate market,” says Dr. David Scott, executive director of the Dr. Phillips Institute for the Study of American Business Activity and professor of finance at the University of Central Florida (UCF).
The statewide existing-home median sales price rose 9 percent to reach $254,800 in the second quarter; a year ago, it was $234,500. In 2001, the second-quarter statewide median sales price was $127,400, which is an increase of about 100 percent over the five-year period. The median is a typical market price where half the homes sold for more, half for less.
This environment is likely to endure across the remaining months of 2006 owing to several factors, Scott says, including the declining rate of growth in the real gross domestic product (GPD); a tepid increase in the number of jobs being created over the past three months; rising conventional mortgage rates; and a rising inventory of homes for sale. He notes that the rising costs of gasoline and energy are starting to strain many household budgets while wages are just barely keeping up with the recent price inflation of about 3.6 percent a year.
Looking to Florida’s existing condominium market, sales of existing condos also decreased during the quarter, with a total of 16,522 condos sold statewide compared to 24,599 in second quarter 2005 for a 33 percent decline, according to FAR. The statewide median sales price for condos rose 1 percent to $219,100 for the three-month period; a year ago, it was $217,900.
The latest economy outlook from the National Association of Realtors® (NAR) notes that the housing market is in the process of stabilizing with little change in overall sales volume expected over the balance of the year. Analysts report that the level of activity remains high historically — 2006 is expected to be the third best year for existing home sales. According to Freddie Mac, the national commitment rate for a 30-year conventional fixed-rate mortgage averaged 6.60 percent in first quarter 2006; last year, it was 6.24 percent.
Among the state’s larger markets, the Orlando metropolitan statistical area (MSA) reported 8,189 existing homes sold for the quarter, a decrease of 23 percent compared to the 10,585 homes sold a year ago. The market’s existing-home median sales price increased 18 percent to $265,500; a year ago, it was $224,500. A total of 1,456 existing condos sold in the market over the three-month period, up 24 percent from a year ago, while the existing-condo median price rose 1 percent to $163,500.
The Gainesville MSA, one of the smaller markets in the state, reported that 992 homes changed hands in the second quarter, down 24 percent compared to 1,297 homes sold a year ago. Over the same period, the market’s existing-home median home price rose 21 percent to $214,300; a year ago, it was $176,400. A total of 426 existing condos sold in the market during the second quarter, up 37 percent from a year ago, while the existing-condo median price rose 16 percent to $146,600.
“The student population is a strong stabilizing factor for our condo market, and with prices rising, condos are a good product for many first-time buyers,” says Deborah Minck, president of the Gainesville-Alachua County Association of Realtors and broker-vice president of Tioga Realty Inc. in Gainesville. “Conditions now are more balanced for buyers and sellers, and the key is working with someone who knows the local housing market. That’s why it is so important for buyers and sellers to work with a Realtor — someone who knows the ins and outs of the local real estate market and can help them with all of the complex details involved in buying or selling a home.”
The Fort Myers/Cape Coral MSA reported single family home sales off 28% Vs. 2nd quarter sales a year ago. Single family home prices were up 2% to $278,800 Vs. $273,500 a year ago. Condominum sales were off 61% in the 2nd quarter of 2006 Vs. 2005, although prices were up 11% to $306,200 from $275,600 from a year ago. According to Brett Ellis of RE/MAX Realty Group, the weakness is an example of over supply due to investor purchases the past several years. “they really just over supplied our market, which hurt us in two ways. Number one, we have more homes for sale than actual buyers who will live in the properties. Number two, investors helped drive up the market such that they influenced how sellers value their properties. Sellers became convinced that each and every one of their homes was worth the Top of the market, regardless of whether there are actually buyers today willing to pay that price. The fact that one day in the past a buyer was willing to pay a certain price doesn’t mean that is the price for ever more. Values go up and they come down, and today they are down from the highs. Some sellers are stuck in yesteryear and refuse to believe what is happening, which further prevents them from selling.”
Two charts showing statistics for Florida and its MSAs are attached. One chart compares the volume of existing, single-family home sales and median sales prices in the second quarter of 2006 to the second quarter of 2005, based on Realtor-closed transactions from local Realtor boards/associations within the MSAs. The second chart compares the volume of existing condo sales and median sales prices in second quarter 2006 to second quarter 2005, based on Realtor-closed transactions from local Realtor boards/associations within the MSAs.
Danforth Lakes Market Update
Currently there are 19 homes on the market with an average list price of $405,684 Of the 19 homes on the market, 1 is pending with a list price of $329,800
6 Listings have closed since January 1, 2006. Average Sale Price was $367,150 2 of the 6 listings were Ellis Team at RE/MAX Listings, giving the Ellis Team a 33% market share of the sold listings this year.
The Ellis Team listed and sold 100% of their listings in Danforth Lakes. This is primarily due to market knowledge, product knowledge of Danforth Lakes homes, and superior marketing.
2006 State of the Market Report
The real estate market is much like a finely tuned jet airplane. To fly at optimal speed and efficiency, the pilot sets the course at optimal altitude, which provides for greatest speed and least resistance. The SW Florida real estate market flew at high altitude from 2001-2003. In 2004, the jet airplane transformed itself into a space shuttle and left the earth’s atmosphere. For two years the shuttle flew at super sonic speed, at altitudes never experienced before.2005 was a year where nothing could stop the shuttle. It was flying faster than the engineers said it could, and seemed unstoppable; until the oxygen sprung a leak. Suddenly, the shuttle was forced to return to earth as there wasn’t enough oxygen to sustain this altitude. Like all re-entries, it can be bumpy and chaotic. The 4th Quarter of 2005 wasn’t bumpy or chaotic. It was as if the world had stopped, and we were flying in slow motion. Speed and altitude dropped quickly. Once the shuttle emerged on radar, it didn’t fly like a loud and confident jet airplane. It felt more like a hot air balloon, drifting slowly, silent and quiet, awaiting word on its future course from the tower. The tower didn’t answer. The flight became choppy in the 1st Quarter of 2006 when everyone realized we were back to flying at earthly speeds and altitude. Sellers began to grasp the gravity of the situation, and made adjustments.
The final altitude has not been set. Once our market finds its optimal altitude, it will once again be in balance. Once our market reaches balance, it will again rise, fly at great speeds and take us all to new heights. No one can say for certain what the correct altitude for this market is, or exactly when we will reach it. One thing we can say with certainty is that the market is balancing itself right before our eyes, and quickly. We are starting to see activity pick up again, either from pent-up demand or price corrections, or both. Once the plane levels we believe we’ll be in for another long and smooth ride. This plane will never land.
Download the full State of the Market Report
If you purchased in 2006, you’ll have to wait until next year to file. If you purchased prior to 2005 and have not filed yet, you still can. If you qulaify, it’s a wise decision to file. Do not wait as it can cost you much more than the $400/yr because you won’t get the cap.
Florida has two bills pending in the legislature regarding Homestead Exemption Portability. We’ll cover what these bills mean to you in a future post.
Real Estate Numbers May Be Inflated By Duplication
When the Realtor closes out the sale in MLS, each MLS reports a sale up to FAR (Florida Association of Realtors). FAR compiles the data and releases a report and chart for the entire state. The report each MLS sends to FAR is raw data, a compilation of summary totals. There is currently no way for FAR to realize the duplicate reportings, so the end report contains inflated data.
This is important for a few reasons:
#1. Billions of dollars worth of decisions are made in the SWFL real estate market, and these numbers are one of the benchmarks builders, developers, investors, businesses, and the buying and selling public use to make decisions about building shopping centers, businesses, homes, communities, and what product mix and at what price points.
#2. Once the duplication problem is rectified, 2006 may appear to be a much worse market because it won’t appear to stack up against 2005, even though 2005 was artificially higher than it really was.
#3. The general public reads that homes appreciated at a certain pace, so they believe their home is worth a certain amount. All real estate is local, so because the overall market was believed to be at a certain appreciation rate, it never was fair to expect every home appreciated at the exact same rate anyway. However, the entire market may have been accidently exagerated, so sellers shouldn’t draw conclusions about today’s market based upon inaccurate data.
If you’re considering buying or selling in today’s market, it pays to consult a professional. Making a mistake in today’s market can cost you in untold ways. We’ll discuss how in a later article posted on this Blog.
Fort Myers Geo Areas
Cape Coral Geo Areas
As you can see, inventory is rising quickly, and the market has swung from a Hot sellers market to a buyers market. The CMI index in October predicted the market would slow, and as you can see, Active listings have swelled while Pending sales have dropped.
We are seeing about a 5 to 1 ratio of new listings entering the market each day to number of homes that go pending, which has lead to a dramatic increase in inventory. How much will this build-up affect prices? Stay tuned and we’ll post more Mini-updates on what is happening in SW Florida Real Estate.
Note, we selected certain geographic areas inside our MLS system for same sales comparisons. The Fort Myers and Cape Coral Geo areas do not encompass the Entire Lee County market, there are actually many more listings than what is shown here. We do feel, however, this is an accuratae representation of what is happening all over SW FLorida, regardless of which Geo area homes are located in.
To search for homes for sale, feel free to shop at www.LeeCountyonline.com